SOX 404: Requirements, Exemptions, and Compliance Checklist

What Is SOX Section 404? 

SOX Section 404 is a component of the U.S. Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, aimed at ensuring the accuracy and reliability of corporate financial statements. It mandates that publicly traded companies establish, maintain, and assess an adequate internal control structure to safeguard the integrity of their financial reporting. The section requires management and external auditors to report on the effectiveness of the company’s internal controls over financial reporting.

The primary goal of SOX 404 is to restore investor confidence by promoting transparency and accountability in the financial practices of businesses. Compliance with this section requires companies to document their financial processes, identify control gaps, implement corrective measures, and disclose this activity as part of the annual financial reporting process. This reduces the likelihood of financial fraud and misstatements, ultimately protecting investors and enhancing market stability.

How Does SOX 404 Impact Financial Reporting Processes? 

SOX Section 404 significantly impacts financial reporting processes by requiring companies to implement, document, and regularly evaluate their internal controls. Each annual financial report of a company must contain a report on the company’s internal control over financial reporting.

Companies must identify all financial processes, such as revenue and procurement, and set controls to ensure accurate reporting. This involves designing controls for the company’s operations, setting thresholds for material variances, and maintaining documentation to prove that controls are effective. 

Additionally, SOX 404 promotes enhanced corporate governance. The creation of independent audit committees to oversee financial reporting and control activities ensures better accountability. This leads to fewer audit adjustments and improved confidence in financial statements, benefiting investors and management. Strong internal controls further reduce the likelihood of fraudulent activities.

Key Subsections of SOX Section 404 

Section 404(a)

Section 404(a) mandates that management of all publicly traded companies must assess and report on the effectiveness of their internal controls over financial reporting (ICFR) annually. This evaluation focuses on the operational effectiveness of controls to prevent errors or fraud in financial reporting. The results are disclosed in the company’s annual filing (Form 10-K). 

Section 404(b)

Section 404(b) requires that external auditors independently assess the company’s internal controls over financial reporting. This ensures that management’s evaluation under 404(a) is accurate. The auditors provide an opinion on the effectiveness of these controls, which is included in the company’s audit report. The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) sets the standards for how auditors conduct this review.

Section 404(c)

Section 404(c) provides exemptions from the 404(b) auditor attestation requirement for certain smaller companies, such as non-accelerated filers and emerging growth companies (EGCs). These organizations, typically with lower public float or revenue, are only required to comply with 404(a), relieving them of the burden of an external audit on their controls​.

Tips from the expert

Steve Moore is Vice President and Chief Security Strategist at Exabeam, helping drive solutions for threat detection and advising customers on security programs and breach response. He is the host of the “The New CISO Podcast,” a Forbes Tech Council member, and Co-founder of TEN18 at Exabeam.

In my experience, here are tips that can help you better navigate SOX 404 compliance:

Leverage automated monitoring tools for internal controls: Automated solutions can continuously monitor internal controls, flagging deviations in real time, which reduces manual oversight and identifies issues early. This is particularly useful for high-volume transactions where human monitoring can miss critical details.

Map key financial risks to strategic objectives: Ensure that your internal controls are not only meeting compliance but also aligned with the company’s strategic financial goals. This ensures that controls are risk-focused and provide business value beyond mere compliance.

Develop a risk-based testing schedule: Prioritize your control testing based on risk profiles. Controls tied to significant financial risks should be tested more frequently and rigorously, while lower-risk controls can be tested less often, optimizing both effort and cost.

Engage in pre-audit “dry runs”: Conduct pre-audit reviews that simulate the formal external audit. These “dry runs” help identify gaps or issues before the external auditor conducts their assessment, allowing for corrective action beforehand and smoother audit outcomes.

Maintain a formalized process for remediation of control deficiencies: Develop a documented, repeatable process for addressing control deficiencies promptly. This should include root-cause analysis, corrective action plans, and timelines to ensure issues are resolved before they become larger risks.

Who Must Comply with SOX 404 and Who Is Exempt?

SOX 404 compliance is mandatory for all publicly traded companies in the United States, including their subsidiaries and foreign entities listed on U.S. stock exchanges. These companies must comply with both Section 404(a) and 404(b), which require management and external auditors to assess the effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting (ICFR). 

Certain smaller companies, such as non-accelerated filers—those with less than $75 million in public float—and emerging growth companies (EGCs) are exempt from the auditor attestation required by Section 404(b). EGCs remain exempt for the first five years following their initial public offering (IPO), provided they do not exceed annual gross revenues of $1.235 billion or issue more than $1 billion in non-convertible debt. 

Additionally, smaller reporting companies (SRCs)—those with less than $250 million in public float—are exempt if they reported less than $100 million in annual revenue​. Private companies and nonprofits are generally not required to comply with SOX 404, but may be encouraged to adopt similar internal controls depending on their business needs or third-party requirements​.

Compliance Checklist for SOX 404 

1. Adopt Recognized Frameworks

Adopting recognized frameworks is beneficial for achieving compliance with SOX 404. Frameworks such as COSO (Committee of Sponsoring Organizations) provide a structured approach to designing, implementing, and evaluating internal controls. These frameworks offer standardized guidelines that help ensure consistency and thoroughness in control measures.

Using recognized frameworks simplifies the compliance process, providing a clear roadmap for establishing effective controls. It also makes the internal control processes more understandable and verifiable for both internal stakeholders and external auditors. Adopting such frameworks enhances the overall effectiveness of internal control systems, making compliance efforts more reliable.

2. Establish Internal Controls

Establishing internal controls is the foundational step towards SOX 404 compliance. Companies must design and implement control measures that effectively mitigate identified risks within their financial reporting processes. These controls should cover all significant aspects of financial transactions, ensuring accuracy, completeness, and reliability.

Once controls are established, it is essential to document them meticulously. This documentation should describe each control’s purpose, methodology, and scope. Detailed documentation provides a clear map of the control landscape, facilitating easy assessment by internal teams and external auditors.

3. Develop and Maintain Documentation

Developing and maintaining thorough documentation is pivotal for SOX 404 compliance. This documentation should capture all aspects of internal control procedures, detailing their design, implementation, and the outcomes of any testing or audits. Proper documentation is essential for demonstrating compliance during audits and reviews.

Documentation should be ongoing and updated regularly to reflect any changes in processes, systems, or controls. It serves as a historical record and a guide for current and future assessments. Well-maintained documentation simplifies the audit process, reduces the risk of oversight, and ensures that all internal controls are clearly understood and effectively communicated across the organization.

4. Test Internal Controls

Regular testing of internal controls is crucial to maintaining SOX 404 compliance. Testing involves evaluating the design and operational effectiveness of controls to ensure they are functioning as intended. This can include manual reviews, automated testing procedures, and walkthroughs of financial processes to identify any gaps or weaknesses.

Testing should be conducted periodically, with the frequency determined by the risk level of the controls. High-risk areas may require more frequent and intense testing compared to lower-risk areas. The results of these tests should be documented and any identified deficiencies addressed promptly to maintain the integrity of the control environment.

5. Integrate with Financial Audit

Integration with financial audit processes is vital for effective SOX 404 compliance. The internal controls must align seamlessly with the broader financial audit requirements, ensuring that both sets of activities support each other. This alignment helps in identifying and addressing financial reporting risks more effectively, resulting in more reliable financial statements.

Coordination between internal control assessments and financial audits also promotes efficiency, as auditors can rely on well-documented and tested controls, reducing the scope and duration of their audits. This integration minimizes disruption to the business operations while ensuring comprehensive coverage of all financial risks and controls.

SOX Compliance with the Exabeam SOC Platform

Understanding the requirements of the regulation is only half the battle when it comes to SOX compliance. To achieve compliance effectively, you will need the right technology stack in place. Tools that help gather the right data and set up the security controls and measures required by SOX regulations will help you achieve compliance faster and reduce risks to your organization.

As the leading Next-gen SIEM and XDR, Exabeam Fusion provides a cloud-delivered solution for threat detection and response. Exabeam Fusion combines behavioral analytics and automation with threat-centric, use case packages focused on delivering outcomes. It can help improve your organization’s overall security profile, leaving you better equipped to maintain compliance with regulations such as SOX.

• Protect Personal Data With GDPR Compliance
• PCI Compliance: A Quick Guide
• What Is the HIPAA Compliance Standard and How to Adhere to It?